" />
Published On: Mon, Jul 17th, 2017

SEC and its Renegades

Few feel comfortable with big brother (or perhaps big sister?) breathing down the neckline of their Curtis & Hawke shirts or Versace skirt suites. The experience could be disorienting. Apart from the considerable discomfort and palpable awkwardness of the contact, the nagging possibility of mischief makes such behavior reprehensible; or so it seems. Unless, of course, the peeping Tom happens to be the Nigerian Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) that makes it its business to peep down the orifices of other people’s wardrobes. In the last few weeks shareholders have had the stock markets chief regulatory agency in their cross hairs as they vent their anger on issues ranging from the shadowy operations of the Nigerian Investors Protection Fund (NIPF) to the decision of the SEC to bump off 20 companies listed on the Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE).”SEC and the NSE seem to have tipped over the deep end of hubris. They are stomping over shareholders rights like two gorillas high on narcotics”, said one aggrieved investor in Lagos recently.
Not many analysts would agree. To be sure, big sister SEC seems to have woken up from a deep, self-induced slumber and come to the startling realization that she had side stepped her statutory responsibilities. Indeed if SEC was not such a beautiful regulator she would have been cashiered and court martialed for criminal negligenceand her brother, the Nigerian Stock Exchange, would have been arraigned for complicity. Both institutions staffed with some of the finest professionals in the business, somehow, dropped the ball by allowing listed companies to continue to enjoy the benefits of quotation without the attendant responsibility of financial accountability to their shareholders. Analysts believe that both SEC and NSE should have stripped-searched the books of companies they recently threatened to delist as far back as 2008 when the market went into a tail spin (of course one can empathize with the two bodies, searching the sagging bodies of aging or, in some cases pre-terminal, corporations is not exactly a thrilling exercise). A company like DAAR Communication was always prone to financial opaqueness. Founded by a man created in the mold of America’s darling corporate spin doctor, Donald Trump (remember Trump Towers?), Raymond Dokpesi, a once –upon-a-time shipping magnate, had grand ideas but dodgy capacity for execution. His sprawling electronic media organization has stumbled, wobbled and slipped quite a few times, both before and after its Initial Public Offer (IPO)in the first quarter of 2008. The major problem with DAAR is its poor corporate governance standards, its relatively high operating expenses and an advertising market that has become bitingly stingy. The company is choke-full of relatives of the Chairman who see themselves as co-inheritors of a broadcast media patrimony. The lack of family independence and transparency in the administration of the organization and its pallid accounting practices makes it an investor’s nightmare. Its quoted price of 50k (down from N5.00 in 2005 and 71kobo in 2009) is an investor’s cry basin. Predictably the company has posted negative after tax earnings in the last half decade and declared zero dividends. Investors in the company are worse than dead, they are in transition to that place only the devil is proud to call home.
As with DAAR so with Starcomms (recent share price 50kobo), a once gutsy CDMA-telecommunications ‘David’ took on the muscular and ripped GSM giants; MTN, Airtel, Globacom, and Etisalat, and got squashed like a bug. Starcomms problems ranged from naïve over trading (the company lived its whole life on unsustainable negative operating cash flow), to poor asset control. Starcomms has severally been accused of corporate and managerial arrogance. Little wonder then that most of its customer, especially those in its niche digital data business, voted with their feet by leaving the company in a pool of red ink. There are speculations that creditors have already encircled the company’s assets awaiting full bankruptcy resolution. As is usual with these cases, equity holders are likely to be sent home with a nice pat on the back, a fresh box of Kleenex tissue (to dry their tears)and some silly consolation speech; but as for money? They are likely to get a lovely cheque with the handsome sum of zero naira and zero kobo. Bankruptcy is a dud and so also is the fate of shareholders locked into bankrupt firms. In the long queue of those that recover money from failed companies equity holders trail a distant last.
A twist to the awkward tale of stock market renegades is Mass Telecomms Innovation Plc (MTI). The company was started in 2002 to provide co-location services to larger telecommunication companies such as MTN, Bharti-Airtel, Etisalat and Globacom. The revised corporate business model was simple but brilliant; to provide masts and other shared technical infrastructure support for an annual rental fee. Unfortunately incompetent management and barefaced thievery brought the company to its knees faster than a bullet. The Frank Karkite-led board of directors on raising tons of money(aboutN6b) from the stock market went allegedly rogue. The situation was so bad the shareholders had to petition the regulatory authorities (SEC and NSE) to investigate the company’s operations.
Equity holders, therefore, can ill afford school yard tantrums; there is an urgent need for irritated investors in these 20 basket-case companies to sit soberly with officials of the SEC and the NSE to work out best case disaster recovery plans. The SEC’s Investors Protection Fund is a rather bizarre creation of the market. Stock markets are not deposit money banks and equity holdings are not the same creatures as bank deposits, therefore, investor protection through a special fund (thinly disguised as a cousin to the deposit protection responsibility of the Nigerian Deposit Insurance Corporation (NDIC)) is at best lame and at worst a painful intrusion into the workings of free market economics. The stock market is neither a social welfare scheme nor an instrument for popular redistribution of wealth, it is a platform for competing investment decisions based on available market and non-market information, and it is a bloody battlefield where the clever rip assets off the stupid and the supremely intelligent take profit from the decidedly dumb. The stock market, rightly, makes no pretensions to being democratic; its primary responsibility is to be efficient.
The SEC and NSE’s primary concerns should not be how to compensate investors for poor investment decisions (and/or poor stock broker selection) through a quirky investor protection fund but, on the contrary, they should be more concerned with how to ensure that the market disseminates price-sensitive information in a manner that does not give one group of investors some market advantage over others. In more technical literature this is usually referred to as ‘asymmetric information’ which leads to rigged markets where people with privileged information within different time frames can profit from buying or selling stocks before competing rivals.
”If you are going to go bust it should be because you took a right turn instead of a left and not because the driver in the next car got his cousin to pour oil on the highway just to ensure that you took the wrong bend. It is always better to go down through your own stupidity than someone else’s criminality, even though the outcome is generally the same,” notes, Anthony Madojemu, Chief Executive Officer of Lagos-based investment firm, Maven Associates.
Madojemu’s observations point to the fact that the roads to both heaven and hell were paved with good intentions, but which to follow should be left to the canny will of individuals. The attempt by the capital markets regulatory agencies to protect clients from the errant actions of stock brokers is commendable but misguided. Financial renegades should be arrested, prosecuted and made to pay up and go to jail. Clients should also be made to bear the cost of due diligence before choosing a broker. Good clients would seek good brokers and sloppy clients would, well, find out the hard way that it pays to be careful.
Brokers with poor transaction histories cannot remain too long in the business and should be allowed to die a quiet and perhaps painful, death. Will this be costly? Certainly, but it would be a lot cheaper than allowing the market create a door stop for incompetent operators and lax investors.

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these html tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Most Shared

Recent posts

  • Breaking: Oshiomhole is new APC National Chairman

      Former Edo State governor, Comrade Adams Oshiomhole is new Chairman of the All Progressives Congress (APC). Oshiomhole was affirmed after he emerged as the sole candidate for the position at the National Convention of the party on Saturday. The former Edo Governor was one of about 14 candidates affirmed unopposed by delegates at the […]

  • PDP expresses concern over Senator Abaribe’s Safety …demands his release by DSS

      By OBINNA EZUGWU The Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) has expressed worry over the safety of Senator Enyinnaya Abaribe, (PDP Abia South), who was arrested by the Directorate of Security Services (DSS) on Friday. The party in a statement by its National Publicity Secretary, Kola Ologbondiyan lamented that the Gestapo-style arrest of Abaribe had further […]

  • Ohanaeze demands Abaribe’s release, say army should produce Kanu

      By OBINNA EZUGWU Apex Igbo socio-cultural group, Ohanaeze Ndigbo has demanded an unconditional release of Senator Enyinnaya Harcourt Abaribe, insisting that the onus lies on the country’s security forces who invaded the Umuahia home of the leader of the Indigenous Peoples of Biafra (IPOB), Nnamdi Kanu to produce him. This was contained in a […]

  • Breaking: DSS arrests Senator Abaribe

    The Department of State Security (DSS) has arrested Senator Enyinnaya Harcourt Abaribe representing Abia  South on the platform of the opposition People’s Democratic Party (PDP) Abaribe who is Chairman of the South East Senate Caucus, has been a vocal critic of the Muhammadu Buhari administration. He was picked up on Friday and no reason has […]

  • Saraki assures Russian investors of conducive business environment

    The President of the Senate, Dr. Abubakar Bukola Saraki, has assured the Russian Government that Nigeria is conducive for investors especially in the oil, gas, agriculture, mining and power sectors of the economy. Saraki stated this during a meeting with the leadership of the Upper Chamber of the Russian Parliament – Federation Council of the […]

  • Seplat Petroleum succumbs to profit taking

    Seplat Petroleum, for the second day running topped the losers’ table on the Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE), dropping by N32.20 to close at N685 per share, amid profit taking. Mr Ambrose Omordion, the Chief Operating Officer, InvestData Ltd, attributed the development to profit taking. Omordion said that the stock was undervalued considering its fundamentals and […]

  • Buhari: How National Assembly mutilated budget

    President Muhammadu Buhari told a shocked nation on Wednesday how the National Assembly mutilated and rewrote the budget proposals for 2018 as presented by the Executive last November. In a brazen usurpation of executive powers, the National Assembly slashed 347 billion Naira in the allocations to 4,700 projects submitted to it  for consideration and introduced 6,403 projects […]

  • Kachikwu: Nigeria opposes boost in crude oil supply

    Minister of state for Petroleum Resources, Dr. Emmanuel Ibe Kachikwu, said Nigeria would advise against additional oil supply to the global market by OPEC and non-OPEC members. Kachikwu made the country’s position known in an interview with journalists on Thursday ahead of the 174th Meetings of the OPEC Conference and the OPEC and non-OPEC Ministerial meeting […]

  • Coronation Merchant Bank CRO emerges RIMAN President

    The Chief Risk Officer of Coronation Merchant Bank; Mr. Magnus Nnoka has been elected as the president of the Risk Management Association of Nigeria (RIMAN). His election  took place  at the 18th Annual International Conference and Annual General meeting of the Association which took place recently at the Eko Hotels and Suites. Now in its […]

  • Wema Bank Introduces Agent Banking in Kano, Targets Retail Sector in North-West

    Wema Bank Plc has introduced agent banking in Kano as it seeks to deepen its retail footprint across informal economic sectors of the North-Western states and to drive financial inclusion within the entire northern region of the country. Agent Bank is a cost-effective medium employed by Banks to provide financial access to unbanked, underbanked, and […]

  • Airtel Restores Hope for Family of Five in 2nd Episode of ATL 4

    The second episode of Airtel Touching Lives (ATL) Season 4, which aired last Sunday, June 17, documented how Airtel literally touched the lives of the Olanrewaju Komolafe family; a family of five, battling with a streak of unending tragedies. The episode, which aired on Africa Magic Family, revealed how Olanrewaju Komolafe, a barber and commercial […]

  • Investors cautious as banking stocks remain weak

    By OKEY ONYENWEAKU As market volatility continues to be more pronounced, investors have become increasingly torn between putting their hard earned money in the money market, capital market and other sectors which might offer superior returns. Market analysts become jittery over the slow paced growth of the economy (1.95 percent), high non-performing bank loans (average […]

  • Renaissance Capital initiates coverage on top Nigerian staple food producers

    Renaissance Capital, a leading emerging and frontier markets investment bank, initiated coverage on the shares of Nigeria’s staple food producers: Flour Mills of Nigeria, Dangote Sugar Refinery, Dangote Flour Mills and NASCON Allied Industries. This coverage aims to provide investors with the in-depth analysis necessary to make informed investment decisions. The initiation report states that […]

  • Anxiety mounts over U.S. interest rate hike

    …expect capital flight, experts warn FELIX OLOYEDE There is growing concern over the effects of U.S. Federal Reserve’s decision to raise its benchmark interest rate, would have on the Nigerian economy as experts expect investors to take a flight. Investors are usually looking out for areas of higher returns and greater political stability. The Federal […]

  • Democracy Day controversy:  How Orji Uzor Kalu masterminded my humiliation

    By Sir Don Ubani The World over, governments, especially democratic governments, place maximum emphasis on protocol. The observance and application of protocol in the affairs of a government determines, to a very reasonable extent, the definition of civility and, of course, respectability it attracts to itself. According to an Elizabethan playwright and dramatist; Jane Smith, […]

  • 2019: Ambode’s re-election bid in jeopardy

    By OBINNA EZUGWU The political future of Lagos State governor, Mr. Akinwumi Ambode is said to hang in the balance as his political godfather, Ashiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu is allegedly plotting his replacement in 2019 over certain unresolved issues. Business Hallmark learnt from sources that Tinubu is under increasing pressure from people around him, notably […]