" /> > Sanusi rocks the boat | Hallmarknews
Published On: Tue, Dec 13th, 2016

Sanusi rocks the boat

… calls for reduction in debt service, cautions against China

By Okey Onyenweaku

With the economy spiralling into what seems to be an unstoppable recession, the first in over twenty years, two central bank chiefs, one a former head of the institution and the other the serving boss have gone into combat mode, as both express divergent opinions on how to pull the economy back from the brink of tragedy.
Sanusi Lamido Sanusi, the present Emir Kano and erstwhile central bank of Nigeria (CBN) chief executive and Godwin Emefiele the banks current boss has expressed divergent views on monetary policy management and the efforts by the CBN to halt the country’s economic slump.
While Sanusi has insisted that the CBN has worsened the country’s economic condition by its twin policies of controlled foreign exchange rate (otherwise known as a dirty float) and capital controls, Emefiele has countered by asserting that the bank’s intervention in the foreign exchange market has been justified by its regular mop up of excess money supply and its commitment to containing domestic inflation which rose from a mild 8.8% in January this year to a staggering 18.3% by November.
Emefiele has insistently argued that the CBN monetary policy rate (MPR) of 14% has been set to ensure the cooling off of spending pressure on the domestic economy and to relieve the foreign exchange market of a torrent of demand from importers.
Sanusi, however, has demurred. The Emir of Kano has insisted that the combination of slack fiscal policy by the federal authorities and high domestic interest rates have prodded the economy into an avoidable downturn caused by tight monetary policy which has served to squeeze private businesses out of existence and devastated local employment with domestic unemployment rate now sitting at a dangerous 36% (up from 7.7% at the beginning of 2015). The current tiff between the two governors is baffling.
Only two years ago, Sanusi Lamido Sanusi was one of the most visible supporters of a President Muhammadu Buhari Presidency. A supposed high profile whistle blower on the alleged crass corruption that occurred during the Goodluck Jonathan administration in 2014, especially the alleged disappearance of about USD$20billion, Sanusi was seen as a man on an anti-corruption mission. This settled well with the perceived frugality of an incoming President Mohammadu Buhari who was also (albeit debatably) seen as a man of Spartan means and noble intentions; creating the erroneous impression of a marriage made in heaven.
It has not taken too much time to show the frailty of the admiration the former CBN boss has for the President and his administration as he has in recent weeks been blistering in his attack on the administrations fiscal and monetary policies. The short-lived love affair between both parties was perhaps not totally unexpected.
While serving as CBN governor in the Goodluck Jonathan administration Sanusi was both fiery and voluble, personality traits that pitted him against his counterparts in the administration several times. He was astonishingly quick to take on socio-economic issues without reference to the national assembly (in relation to appropriation) or even the President himself (in respect of policy direction). Indeed, Sanusi was a freewheeling economic agent with independent monetary and fiscal fiat. He spent money when and where he felt it was needed as he increasingly took on the role of chief economic coordinator (a role officially assigned to Dr Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala who at the time was the Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister for the Economy).
It was not out of character for the new Emir of Kano as erstwhile CBN boss to spend money on economic issues he felt strongly about, resulting in a floodgate of ‘special intervention’ accounts at the Bank ranging from funds for manufacturing to funds for aviation and then funds for special issues such as rehabilitation of victims of terrorist attacks. Sanusi’s social consciousness has never stopped him from using public money to address public issues, who decides those issues is another matter entirely. This, inevitably, would set the tone for his current anger with managers of the economy and the hardship these policies seem to be inflicting on the local population.
Sanusi who was suspected to have strongly supported the Buhari Presidency in 2015 has found it difficult to remain on the side-lines of debate over the direction of the economy and the society. The slowness in executive decision making and policy implementation has drained the private sector of its vitality. Over three million jobs have been lost between 2015 and 2016 as companies fall into bankruptcy or operational unsustainability one after the other. Only recently Erisoco Industries suspended production and put the livelihoods of over 1,500 workers in jeopardy as the company had found it impossible to fend of the consequences of a conflicting foreign currency policy where the CBN was alleged to favour the allocation of foreign exchange to importers of finished tomato paste products rather than to local manufacturers of the good. Even Aliko Dangote, Nigeria’s foremost industrialist, has recently had to cave in to pressures to lay off workers as production at his plants have sunk on the back of lower consumer demand.
Both rich and poor are beginning to express anger, anxiety and hopelessness about the worsening economy. Hunger is exacerbating by the day. The country’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) has plunged from -2.1 per cent in the second quarter 2016 to -2.24 per cent in the third quarter 2016.
Sadly, the foreign exchange rate has reeled off the track as Naira exchanges for the dollar at N 475/$1, inflation has hit the roof at over 18 per cent and lending rates still hover at a scary 30%.
Feeling strongly that the managers of the economy have derailed, Sanusi has not only advised, but has also warned in strong terms that government should do the right things to refocus the economy.
The Emir of Kano and former CBN Governor has condemned plans by President Muhammadu Buhari to borrow $29,960 billion for the country. He doubted the possibility of any country or international organisation lending Nigeria such a huge amount of money given that her economy is not stable and predictable and has five exchange rates.
Sanusi has been consistent in criticising Mr. Buhari’s economic policies. First, he told Buhari that his government was drifting and would likely end up like that of President Goodluck Jonathan if he does not reverse focus.
“I can tell you for free, if the Senate today approves that we can borrow $30 billion, honestly, no one will lend us,” he said.
“It should be approved and I will like to see how you will go to the international market with an economy that has five exchange rates.
“There is one rate for petroleum marketers, there is interbank rate, there is another for money market operators such as western union, money gram, there is bureau de change rate and there is a special rate you get when you call the CBN for a transaction.
“So, who will borrow you when they don’t know your exact reserve and exchange rate? I want to see who will borrow you money when the Niger Delta bombing of oil is there ‎when the main source of the loan repayment is oil.”
He advised Federal government to involve private sector investments, increase capital expenditure, be cautious with China who is killing Nigeria’s textile and other local industries, reduce its debt service through greater loan concession. He also asked for tax incentives and other benefits to encourage the private sector.
Recently, too, Sanusi had accused the CBN of lending to the Federal Government above the limits stipulated by the CBN Act of 2007.
He revealed that CBN’s lending to the government since President Muhammadu Buhari came to office had spiked from about N1.5 trillion to over N4.5 trillion.
“CBN claims on the FGN now tops N4.7 trillion, equal to almost 50 per cent of the FGN’s total domestic debt. This is a clear violation of the Central Bank Act of 2007 (Section 38.2), which caps advances to the FGN at five per cent of last year’s revenues. Has CBN become the government’s lender of last or first resort?”
He expressed fear that the country was already over- burdened with heavy debts, stating that out of every N1 Nigeria makes, 40 kobo goes to debt and 60 kobo is left for salaries, health, education, power, infrastructure.
He also warned the government against continuing to blame previous administrations for the nation’s woes, saying what was important was for the administration to concentrate on putting the nation back on the path of progress.
Sanusi (WIKIPEDIA)
President Umaru Musa Yar’Adua nominated Sanusi as Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria on 1 June 2009 and his appointment was confirmed by the Senate on 3 June 2009, in the middle of a global financial crisis. Analysts believed that Sanusi’s tempered mien would serve as a counterpoise to the more aloof disposition of his predecessor, Charles Chukwuma Soludo.[10] Based on his past record, it seemed probable that as governor of the central bank he would impose stricter controls.
In August 2009, the Sanusi led the Central Bank to “rescue” Afribank, Intercontinental Bank, Union Bank, Oceanic Bank and Finbank by bailing them out with 400 billion naira of public money, and dismissed their chief executives. Some point to other factors including religious, ethnic and existing bank records and plans to say he in fact had a hidden agenda. He said “We had to move in to send a strong signal that such recklessness on the part of bank executives will no longer be tolerated.” 16 senior bank officials faced charges that included fraud, lending to fake companies, giving loans to companies they had a personal interest in and conspiring with stockbrokers to boost share prices, and today he has been appointed as the Emir of Kano by Gov. Rabi’u Musa Kwankwaso of Kano following the departure of Alh. Ado Bayero. In September 2009, he said that 15 of the current 24 Nigerian banks might survive reform in the banking sector.
In a wide-ranging interview with the Financial Times in December 2009, Sanusi the extensive reforms that he had initiated since taking office, dubbed by some as the “Sanusi tsunami”. Some believe that he had a personal vendetta against some of the bank CEOs while others point to proof of mismanagement of funds by some of the CEOs, most notably Cecelia Ibru as justification for the steps he implemented. He noted that there was no choice but to attack the many powerful and interrelated vested interests who were exploiting the financial system, and expressed his appreciation of support from the Presidency, the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, the finance minister and others.

In January 2010, Sanusi said that banks will only want to give credit to Nigeria’s small and medium enterprises (SMEs), if the government gives adequate attention to the provision of infrastructure.

In January 2010, Sanusi admitted that since 2005 the Central Bank had not conducted routine examinations of the 14 banks allocated to it under the sharing arrangement with Nigerian Deposit Insurance Corporation (NDIC). Abubakar Nagona, president of Integrated Development and Investment Service (IDIS), a venture capital investment company urged Sanusi to “not be cowed and succumb to undue pressure from operators of the same sector he is striving to bring sanity to.” At a February 2010 conference on banking in Nigeria, Sanusi described his blueprint for reforming the Nigerian financial system. He said that it was built around four pillars of enhancing the quality of banks, establishing financial stability, enabling healthy financial sector evolution and ensuring that the financial sector contributes to the real economy. Talking later that month, Sanusi said that the crash in the capital market was due to high level of financial illiteracy on the part of Nigerian investors.
The Banker recognized him as the Central Bank Governor of the Year 2010 citing his radical anti-corruption campaign aimed at saving 24 banks on the brink of collapse and pressing for the managers

However ,the Central Bank of Nigeria is worried by the barrage of criticism and attacks it receives daily. But the criticism that appear to hurt it most is the one that comes from Godwin Emefiele’s predecessor, the new Emir of Kano, Muhammadu Sanusi II, who CBN said has a better channel through which to advise the apex Bank.
Emefiele
“It is easy to criticise from outside but my advice is not to sit back in a garden and call press men and begin to raise criticisms that are untrue and unsubstantiated.
“We need advice of former CBN governors, there are channels they can use but not sit in their garden and call pressmen to raise criticism and say what is not true.” Said Emefiele
Sanusi who has only approved of one of the policies of the CBN recently ( Maintaining the rates, MPR at 14%, the Cash Reserve Ratio at 22.50 per cent and the Liquidity Ratio at 30 per cent) had not seen much deviation from his own policies in his days as CBN boss.
He targeted inflation , even though it was low because there was better and higher revenue from crude which enabled him defend the naira with huge funds from the reserves, he had also spent huge funds on interventions to some critical sectors without appropriation. The N100million he donated to victims of that bomb attack in Kano State raised concerns.
Sanusi also claims to have cut down on spending. ‘’In 2012, CBN spent N38billion on mint printing down from the N49billion spent in 2011. In 2013, we spent N35billion and, in my 2014 budget, my plan was to spend N30billion. So, we have been bringing down the cost of printing’’,
Responding, the Presidency said the Emir of Kano did not have the facts on the issues over which he criticised President Buhari’s administration.
The CBN governor said it was better to provide creative advice that would help the economy than sitting back criticising.
Emefiele said: “It is easy to criticise from outside but my advice is not to sit back in a garden and call press men and begin to raise criticisms that are untrue and unsubstantiated.
“We need advice of former CBN governors, there are channels they can use but not sit in their garden and call pressmen to raise criticism and say what is not true.”

The CBN governor advised Nigerians to look inwards in order to come out of the present economic predicament.

He lamented that Nigerians spend about £2 billion on their children studying abroad at the detriment of the the nation’s educational sector.
Emefiele further blamed the elite who preferred imported materials to local ones for the current crisis, and wondered why CBN is often condemned whenever it takes decisions to reposition the economy.
“When you introduce a new policy and people do not complain, then that policy is not working. But when policies are introduced and people are shouting and complaining, then the policies have reached the right place.
“It means the policy is working. We should not use our hands to destroy ourselves, we should not use our hands to kill ourselves,” he said.
Emefiele’s view on the economy reveals that Nigeria has been dealing with the effects of three serious and simultaneous global shocks, which began around the third quarter of 2014. These according to him include: ‘’The over 70 percent drop in the price of crude oil, which contributes the largest share of our Foreign Exchange Reserves and Federal Government Revenues; ▪Geopolitical tensions along critical trading routes in the world including between Russia and Western Powers, Saudi Arabia and Iran, etc.; and The end of Quantitative Easing and Normalization of Monetary Policy by the United States’ Federal Reserve Bank’’,

‘’Given the sharp drop in oil prices, Federation Account Allocations to States have dropped by an average of about N2 billion monthly per State, which partly explains their inability to meet some basic recurrent expenditures including payment of workers’ salaries. Similarly, average inflows of foreign exchange into the CBN have fallen by over US$2.3 billion every month over the last 26 months’’, he said
Emefiele had asked, could we have been better prepared to deal with this downturn? I guess my answer is a resounding yes! Every economy goes through phases of booms and bursts, peaks and valleys, highs and lows, prosperity and difficulty. Contrary to correct policy prescriptions during times of boom, we opened up our economy to “allcomers” and dropped all capital controls. At some point, we received more than US$23 billion in “hot money” FPIs in the country in a particular year. Monies that could easily evaporate at the slightest hint of an economic slowdown. Recall that in September 2008, Nigeria’s FX Reserves hit a whopping US$62 billion, even after we had spent about US$12 billion settling our external debt obligations. What did we do with the money?

‘’Let me note at this juncture that every one of these developments has a direct impact on our FX Reserves. When I assumed office in June 2014, our FX Reserves had fallen from the 14 aforementioned high of US$62 billion in 2008 to only US$37 billion! Yet, demand for FX has reached an all-time high of over US$1.2 billion per week or US$4.8 billion per month’’, Emefiele said.
Some analysts have thrown their weight in to the debate. However, some of have said that government reserves a right to borrow money from the CBN but she must do that based on certain principles that keeps it at a reasonable minimum.
“The principle is that the CBN should be kept to their minimum. That is what IMF convention detects. And we are all members of IMF. Nigeria is a member and many other countries. And for the sake of sound public finance, they have said it should be kept to a minimum because the Central Bank of a country is not a bank of first resort. It is a bank of last resort. So, if we keep on borrowing and borrowing from the CBN, it defeats the purpose of sound fiscal management.
A very common Nigerian adage says that when two elephants fight the verdant shrubs under them tend to suffer, in the asymmetric conflict between Sanusi and Emefiele, the adage could prove wrong. The difference between the two economists may enrich and perhaps redirect policy in the broader interest of Nigerians.

Facebook Comments

comments

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these html tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Recent posts

  • Arms seizure raises concerns over proliferation of security agencies at ports

    By FUNSO OLOJO The interception last Sunday by the Nigeria Customs Service of cache of high calibre arms made up of 661 units of brand new Tomado pump action rifles on the street of Lagos has once against raised serious concerns among the agitated industry stakeholders who have now renewed their calls for the review […]

  • Michael Ajayi: The bridge-builder bows out of NPA

    FUNSO OLOJO “I am a Marxist-socialist who believes that a common man deserves a better life”. That is the philosophy which underpins the life and actions of Chief Micheal Kayode Ajayi, the retiring General Manager of Nigerian Ports Authority(NPA). The ebullient image-maker of the super-rich government agency bows out of the organization this March after […]

  • N4bn 7UP loss exposes rot in real sector

    Okey Onyenweaku Seven up Plc, in a result that has kept investors shuddering, recently posted a mind-boggling N4.8b loss for the third quarter of the year 2016. The result, a total collapse from its 2015 third quarter profit after tax of N2.2b, signposts one of the worst operating performances for the carbonated soft drink manufacturer […]

  • Skye Bank crisis worsens

    …customers, shareholders’ express anxiety Okey Onyenweaku Against the background of an implosion in the earnings of commercial banks in Nigeria, Skye Bank Plc has again grabbed headlines for unsavory reasons. Indeed, emerging developments in the bank underscore a deepening operating and management crisis and has set up the stage for an epic battle to save […]

  • First Bank leads four Nigerian banks in Top 500 Global Banking Brands

        First Bank of Nigeria Limited has been named as the most valuable banking brand in Nigeria in The Top 500 Banking Brands of The Banker magazine of the Financial Times  and Brand Finance, London, United Kingdom for the sixth consecutive time.   According to a press release issued on Sunday by the Country […]

  • N4bn loss: Guinness Nigeria faces more challenges

    Okey Onyenweaku The once cheerful faces of shareholders of Guinness Nigeria Plc has suddenly turned gloomy as their company’s fortunes continues to fall into a never-ending hole. Unable to ride on the back of an increasingly weaker consumer market for alcohol, the company found its 2016 financial statement dipped in red ink as it posted […]

  • Forex crisis: $30bn loan in jeorpady

      Okey Onyenweaku Anxiety is beginning to cloud the possibility of international lenders to give Nigeria the $ 30 billion she needs to restructure her sagging economy. The Nation’s economy which slipped into a recession in the first quarter of 2016 has continued to deepen the government’s desperation for far reaching solutions. The recent drop […]

  • Anxiety over Banks’ year end results

    Okey Onyenweaku Anxiety has begun to drench the expectations of analysts and other stakeholders alike as they continue to fret over the release of year end 2016 results for banks listed on the Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE). The anxiety of investors reflects the adverse impact a full year of falling gross domestic product (GDP) growth […]

  • Prospects of market recovery bleak

      .           Stocks lose N4trn in 3 years; Blue chips shed 47% value Okey Onyenweaku Nine years after the melt down of global financial markets in 2008, the Nigerian stock market has taken a frightening tumble as the Nigerian All Shares Index (ASI) dropped by an astonishing 60% or -10.7% per annum on a compound […]

  • NICON Insurance, micro finance banks sign MoU to boost Nigeria’s business frontiers

      NICON Insurance has signed a memorandum of Understanding with the National Association of Micro Finance Banks (NAMFB) in order to stem the harsh effects of economic recession on small scale businesses in the country. The pact, sealed by NICON with the umbrella micro finance body, composed of 978 members, is said to be targeted […]

  • Lloyd’s threat: Anxiety as AON struggles to save Nigerian airlines

    There is unease among domestic airlines in Nigeria following a threat by Lloyd’s of London, the world’s leading insurance market, to blacklist them over irregular payment of premiums. This is another unfortunate consequence of a biting economic recession Nigeria is currently undergoing which has among other things thrown the nation into acute shortage of foreign […]

  • Ports get harmonised support portal

      Maritime activities closed last Friday with the Nigerian Ports Authority (NPA) saying the nation’s ports are ready to absorb increase in imported vehicles expected from government’s ban on importation of vehicles through land borders. The Managing Director of NPA, Ms Hadiza Usman, gave the indication in Lagos to mark her 100 days in office. […]

  • NDIC, CBN set up committee to study digital currency

      The Managing Director, Nigeria Deposit Insurance Commission (NDIC), Alhaji Umaru Ibrahim, has said that the commission and CBN had set up a committee to look into the trending “digital currency, ‘Bitcoin’. Ibrahim said this at the ongoing 2016 Workshop for Financial Correspondents in Kaduna. The theme of the workshop is “Economic Recession and the […]

  • Rice smuggling thrives in spite of ban

      The smuggling of rice through the land borders has continued to thrive in Badagry area of Lagos State in spite of the Federal Government’s ban on the practice. Markets along Badagry Expressway close to Seme border, are stocked with various varieties of smuggled rice, especially as the Christmas season approaches. A smuggler, who identified […]

  • Ugwuanyi’s fate hangs in the balance as Appeal Court fails to decide

    The protracted legal tussle between the Enugu State governor, Hon. Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi and former senator representing Enugu North senatorial zone, Ayogu Eze is poised to last longer than anticipated as the Appeal Court sitting in Abuja and presided over by Justice Tinuade Akomolafe-Wilson last week Thursday, reserved judgment on an appeal filed by Eze seeking […]

  • Hallmarknews Backpage

    On November 8, 2016 Americans elected Donald Trump as their 45th president.  By the time you’re reading this, Mr. Trump would have named all his nominees for leadership of various government departments. The president-elect, who will be inaugurated on January 20, 2017, has not only unveiled the lineup of his cabinet, he has also specified […]


Take a Poll

Please wait...

Subscribe to our newsletter

Enter your email address and be the first to know when our article is published.