" /> Budget 2017: Analysts worry about implementation | Hallmarknews
Published On: Mon, May 15th, 2017

Budget 2017: Analysts worry about implementation

By TESLIM SHITTA-BEY

Nigeria’s 2017 budget got a nod of approval by members of the national assembly last week five months after its original presentation and several weeks after back room horse trading with the executive. The budget was increased by a relatively modest N143 billion from the original presentation to the parliament by President Muhammadu Buhari in December last year, pulling the fiscal plan up 2 per cent from N7.3 trillion as presented by the president to N7.441 trillion as recently approved by the assembly.

As budgets go, the document is remarkably bland except for a few dodgy assumptions that could send the governments books spiraling into an ugly deficit of between 3 and 4 per cent of gross domestic output (GDP). The fiscal appropriations as reconfigured by the NASS is premised on an average international oil price of US$44.50 per barrel for the year 2017, which represents a 4.7per cent increase over the US$42.50 the executive had proposed early. Several analysts see this as brash and gravely dangerous.

In the face of rising global stockpiles, the international price of crude oil has slipped below US$50 over the last two weeks for, admittedly, technical reasons of forward traders unbundling their positions, but which could yield to more fundamental factors such as the unusually warm winter in Europe and America reducing potential demand for fuel and the rise in output by American shale oil producers. By raising the average budgetary benchmark of fuel prices in a indicatively soft global market, the legislature has, inadvertently, breached one of the classic tenets of proper accounting, conservatism. Analysts believe that it would be better for oil prices to skim slightly over budget calculations than to fall below budgetary estimates leading to wider and unanticipated fiscal deficit.

‘We have got to temper our gluttony’ says Dr Vincent Uwani, Director Research and Advocacy, Lagos Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LCCI), ‘even though the global economy may grow faster in 2017 than in 2016 (International Monetary Fund predicts 2017 growth of 3.5 per cent as compared to 3.1 per cent in 2016) the continued rise in crude stockpiles in international markets suggest that the NASS should have kept to the executives original benchmark of US$42.50’. According to Uwani, ‘unbridled optimism is just as dangerous as unhinged pessimism, the original budget price of crude oil at US$42.50 gave just about enough room to serve as a fallback cushion of 16 per cent now the cushion has collapsed to 12 per cent, a harder potential landing point’ he says.

But beyond shaky price assumptions the new budget estimate presumes average oil output at 2.2 million barrels per day (which analysts are not too worried about, though some would have preferred a lower figure to accommodate possible mild disruptions). The budget also rests on a US$/N exchange rate of N305/US$, this could prove a useful peg as a price above this rate would allow the government room to accrue more revenue in naira than the budget specifies. This would enable the government stimulate the economy and reduce unemployment from the staggering official rate of 18 per cent (up from 7 per cent in 2015).

This perhaps explains the self-congratulation and effusive praise the senate president, Senator Bukola Saraki, gave both the legislature and the executive for the new budget. It also to some extent explains why the Senator was enthusiastic about the ability of the budget to lead the economy out of recession. The trouble with the NASS’s emotional joy ride, however, is that if prices continue to decline (currently at US$48 or 9.4 per cent lower than the US$53 per barrel at the turn of the year, see chart) then total dollar receipts could cave in and actual naira volumes available for spending by the authorities could implode. ‘We might be walking on eggshells this year’ notes Olusegun Atere, head of portfolio management at Imperial Finance & Investment, ‘if oil prices dip below the budget benchmark we could be looking at a horrible budget deficit with increasing bond market activity; indeed bond yields could rise phenomenally this year as prices crash and the fed becomes forced to raise already towering coupon rates to keep investors happy’ he notes.

Bond yields on 10 year instruments have climbed from just over 12 per cent in January 2016 to 14.5 per cent in October of the same year only to settle at a more recent support price of 16.2 per cent in April 2017 (see chart 4). The steepening yield curve suggest that investors are wary of growth in domestic inflation (currently put at 17.9 per cent) and are pessimistic about the years fiscal balance with analysts frowning at the 24 per cent debt service component of the new budget. Even though Nigeria’s total debt stock at US$64 billion is roughly a third of its gross domestic product (GDP), debts service obligations as a proportion of annual budgets is increasingly crippling economic expansion and weakening fiscal policy as a tool for macroeconomic management.

A major problem with Nigeria’s creeping debt trap is that there are no buffers to absorb the shock of declining foreign revenues from oil if the price of the commodity plummets. The capital component of the budget is less than a third of total expenditure and not all the projects related to this budget item are self financing or self –sustaining, indeed a large number of the projects are ‘social’, meaning that they do not have a refinancing framework. The consequence of this is that debt service obligation would become a major drag on the economy if oil prices plunge any further. To plug the hole the fiscal authorities would have to drastically raise domestic taxes (especially value added tax (VAT)) and cut back recurrent spending meaning a massive loss of either public sector jobs or a deep cut in workers’ pay. In other words the jolly economic outlook orchestrated by the executive and the legislature may end up being clever by half.

As a side bar to the budgets less obvious challenges is the issue of whether the current fiscal deficit is predominantly structural or cyclical. A structural deficit is a deficit that persists despite the economy being at full employment meaning that normal government policies of increasing money supply or cutting taxes do not matter. They simply cannot drag the economy up. A cyclical deficit on the other hand occurs as a result of a recessionary downturn and usually responds top governments fiscal and monetary stimulus.

With a 2016 gross domestic product (GDP) of N148.5 trillion (US$486.8 billion), a tax rate of 30 per cent, full employment rate of unemployment estimated at 10 per cent and a 2017 budget deficit of N2.7 trillion, the 2017’s underlying cyclical deficit is -N3.5 trillion with no structural deficit at all. This is a bit difficult to accept and the problem with the calculation is that Nigeria’s unemployment rate it so high relative to the full employment rate of growth of GDP that splitting the deficit down to a structural component is difficult as most of it happens to be cyclical.

This, however, suggests that active government intervention through monetary and fiscal policy measures should be adequate in kicking the recession can down the road a few meters. Says Peter Folorunso, Managing Director of investment firm, Freewill Nigeria, ’we have a good opportunity to gain some fiscal balance with growth here if the government does not go overboard with its external borrowings and if capital expenditure is focused on building the nations stock of domestic infrastructure’.

Indeed, the budgets real as distinct from its ’nominal’ deficit should come in at around –N615 billion in 2017 meaning that the fiscal burden of government is not as large as it seems on first observation (the government appears to have ‘inflated’ its debt and reduced its real burden on fiscal finance). The assumption here is that total debt (foreign and local) will be about US$64 billion in 2017 and the budget deficit would be at about N2.7 trillion, with inflation hovering at about 17 per cent. This gives the finance ministry ample room to expand fiscal policy. Nevertheless the fed still need to reel in its internal and external borrowing appetite. The problem is not just that of immediate debt management, which could get dicey in the course of the year, as it is one of inter-generational responsibility. The people piling up the debt today will not be around to see to its repayment in the next five to twenty years.

Budget 2017 may indeed have some redeeming features such as its commitment to pushing economic growth and spending the country out of a gripping recession, but going into a spending spree without carefully considering the implications for a younger generation of Nigerian tax payers is the depiction of hubris gone into overdrive; it is both callous and mean.

Source: Passed 2017 National Assembly Budget Appropriations

Source: Passed 2017 National Assembly Budget Appropriations

 

 

 

 
US$ 48 per barrel

Source: Trading Economics

 

 

 

 

 
 
16.2% per annum

Source: Trading Economics, Central Bank of Nigeria

 

 

Source:  National Bureau of Statistics (NBS), Q1* and full year 2017**represent Business Hallmarks forecast

Displaying 1 Comments
Have Your Say
  1. […] Budget 2017: Analysts worry about implementation […]

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these html tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Recent posts

  • Time is ripe for rates cut, says Rewane as inflation slows further in Oct.

    FELIX OLOYEDE This is the appropriate time for the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) to cut benchmark monetary rates after inflation rate slows down for the ninth consecutive time in October, said Mr Bismarck Rewane, Managing Director, Financial Derivatives. The National Bureau of Statistics on Tuesday released Consumer Price […]

  • ELAN National Lease Conference Focuses on Revamping Nigerian Economy

    FELIX OLOYEDE In furtherance of its objective of promoting the business of leasing in Nigeria, Equipment Leasing Association of Nigeria (ELAN) has concluded plans to organise the 15th Annual National Lease Conference with focus on revamping the Nigerian economy. The conference which is the biggest gathering of stakeholders in the leasing industry is expected to […]

  • Nigeria-centric restaurant, Labule, opens new outlet in Lagos

    Labule, Nigeria-centric restaurant, operated by an indigenous company, Roots Foods Limited, offering real Nigerian local delicacies in a unique environment that combines the setting of a modern quick service restaurant with that of an African setting of a local ‘buka’, has opened a new outlet on Admiralty Road in Lekki Phase 1, Lagos. The brand […]

  • Nigerian banks shine in Ghana

    By JOHNMARK UKOKO Nigerian banks have been credited with “revolutionizing “the banking sector in Ghana, due to the many innovations they brought to Ghana’s banking sector. The Ghana Deputy Minister of Trade and Investment Hon. Carlos Kingsley Ahenkorah said in Lagos that the innovation and transformation of the Ghana’s banking sector is credited to the […]

  • Ajimobi moves to save Oyo APC from disintegration

    By OLUSESAN LAOYE The seeming crisis in Oyo APC has now forced the Governor of the state, Abiola Ajimobi, to begin consultations with stakeholders to convinced members on why they must come together as a body to face the 2019 general elections, Although the internal crisis is yet to break open as the aggrieved party […]

  • YolaDisCo sale stalled as no potential buyers emerge

    By ADEBAYO OBAJEMU Two years after the core investors of the Yola Electricity Distribution Company, YolaDisCo, declared a force majeure owing to their inability to operate under the reign of terror unleased by Boko Haram, the Federal Government is yet to find any investor interested in operating the utility company, it has been learnt. In […]

  • Company Analysis: Much Ado about Seplat

      By TESLIM SHITA-BEY The oil and gas sector has had a bumpy since the beginning of 2017 with local oil major, Seplat, seeing its financials whipped raw by prior year liabilities despite rising revenues over the nine months (9M). The company in the last two years has moved from being distinctively bad to singularly […]

  • How to start a photography business

    By ZUBAIR DANIE While photography could be accounted for as a full blown course in any offering institution of learning for professionalism, the field equally provides a platform for individuals whose passion it is to project images as a form of livelihood. The socio-cultural aspect of Nigerians that play host of events like: wedding, naming, […]

  • BOFE to celebrate unsung heroes in local communities

    OluwasolaJesuseitan, a brand and advertising expert, is an advocate of sustainable brand communications. He is also the founder, Business Owners Forum Enterprise (BOFE), a non-profit making organization, which seeks to build the capacity of business owners in and around Akute, Ogun State. He tells FELIX OLOYEDE in this interview of his organization is promoting business […]

  • Lager wars: Who wins?

    By JOHNMARK UKOKO Nigeria has many lager beer producing companies, some have been in existence for over 50 years while others are quite new in existence in the country. Some of these companies that have over the years churned out millions, if not billions of bottles of beer to Nigerian drinkers are: Nigeria Breweries Plc, […]

  • Nestle sparkles in Q3 results

    By OKEY ONYENWEAKU As the packaged Consumer goods (PCG) sector struggles to stay ahead of falling consumer demand, companies such as Nestle Nigeria plc are bucking the trend of businesses with shrinking bottom lines. Indeed the multi-product packaged goods producer has seen earnings rise to mind boggling with its pre-tax profit rising by a stunning […]

  • 2018 Budget proposals renew old anxieties

          FELIX OLOYEDE   Mixed reactions trailed the presentation of the 2018 federal government budget by President Muhammadu Buhari to the National Assembly (NASS) last week. Public policy analysts have expressed moods from the congenially positive to the outright incredulous. The staggering N8.6 trillion expenditure plan is one of the most audacious in […]

  • Anambra 2017: Obiano battles for life

    By Obinna Ezugwu The time has finally arrived. On Saturday the people of Anambra State will head to the polls to either renew the mandate of the incumbent state governor, Chief Willie Obiano who is running for a second term in office, or elect fresh hands from among other prominent contenders, including Mr. Oseloka Obaze […]

  • (Editorial) CBN’s BVN distraction and matters arising

    Nigeria’s fiscal and monetary authorities have a frustrating way of responding to the seizure of private assets; they typically gloat with glazed eyes over private citizen’s money ready to pounce on the cash like a pack of hyenas starved witless. The recent order by the Central Bank of Nigeria that customer accounts that are not […]

  • 12 Yoga tips for beginners

    The popularity of yoga has soared in the last decades, and it seems that every other friend and acquaintance of ours is already practicing it. But don’t let it fool you into thinking it is easy: yoga is quite challenging, especially for beginners. The good news is that there are some practical tips to make […]

  • Finally, embattled IGP, Ibrahim Idris, appears before Senate

    The Inspector General of Police, Ibrahim Idris, has arrived before the Senate ad hoc committee set up to investigate the allegations and counter-allegations between him and Senator Isa Misau. The IGP was accompanied by his lawyer, Alex Iziyon (SAN) and Special Assistant to the President on National Assembly Matters (Senate), Senator Ita Enang.   Details […]


Visit us on Google+